[Washington Post] Last week, the nation focused its attention on the 10-year anniversary of Hurricane Katrina, the most destructive hurricane in U.S. history. As bad as the storm was, though, it wasn’t the worst storm that could have possibly hit New Orleans.
That’s true of many, many other places, too. And now, in a new study
in Nature Climate Change, Princeton’s Ning Lin and MIT’s Kerry Emanuel
demonstrate that when it comes to three global cities in particular —
Tampa, Fla., Cairns, Australia, and Dubai, United Arab Emirates — there
could come a storm that is much worse than anything in recent memory (or
in any memory).
Granted, these theoretical storms are also
highly unlikely to occur — in some cases, they are 1-in-10,000-year
events, or even rarer. The researchers refer to these possible storms as
“gray swans,” riffing on the concept of a “black swan” event, an
unpredictable catastrophe, or highly impactful event. A “gray swan,” by
contrast, can indeed be predicted, even if it is extremely rare.
The purpose of the study is “to raise awareness of what a very low
probability, very high impact hurricane event might look like,” said
Emanuel. The gray swan storms were generated by a computer model that
“coupled” together, in the researchers’ parlance, a very high-resolution
hurricane model with a global climate model. That allowed the
researchers to populate the simulated world with oodles of different
“When you do hundreds and hundreds of thousands of
events, you’re going to see hurricanes that are unlike anything you’ve
seen in history,” said Emanuel, a key theoretician behind the equations
determining the “maximum potential intensity” of a hurricane in a given climate. Indeed, he has published in the past
that a theoretical “hypercane” with winds approaching 500 miles per
hour is possible in scenarios where an asteroid hits the Earth and
radically heats up ocean waters, far beyond their normal temperature.
So what did the researchers see? Let’s take Tampa Bay, first. It hasn’t
been hit by a major hurricane since 1921 — but that storm drove a 3- to
3.5-meter (10- to 11-foot) storm surge and caused dramatic damage.
Earlier, in 1848, another storm produced a 4.6-meter surge (about 15
Why is Tampa Bay so vulnerable? Check out any good map that shows the
water depth (the bathymetry) around the Florida peninsula. It’s deep
off the east coast. But there’s an extraordinarily broad continental
shelf off the west coast. And although the city of Tampa, proper, sits
at the head of Tampa Bay, relatively far from the mouth and well removed
from the barrier islands that get battered by the waves from the Gulf
of Mexico, that’s a more vulnerable spot than you’d think.
can get much larger surges where the offshore waters are shallow, as is
true along the west, but not the east coast of Florida. Also, surges can
amplify by being funneled into bays,” Emanuel said Monday in an e-mail.
new method allows the researchers to show that a worse storm than these
historical examples is possible, especially with sea level rise and
global warming. They simulated 2,100 possible Tampa Bay hurricanes in the
current climate, and then 3,100 each for three time periods (2006
through 2036, 2037 through 2067, and 2068 through 2098) in an unchecked
global warming scenario. In the current climate, the study found
that a 5.9-meter (19-foot) storm surge is possible, in a strong Category
3 hurricane following a similar track to Tampa’s classic 1921 and 1848
storms. Moreover, in a late 21st century climate with global warming run
amok, the worst-case scenario generated by the model included a very
different storm track, moving north along Florida’s Gulf Coast and then
swerving inland at Tampa, that generated an 11.1-meter (nearly 37-foot)
surge. Read More